The Badge Archive

Scout leaders must find a balanced approach that teaches scouts responsible device usage while maintaining the focus, engagement, and safety of scouting activities. By implementing clear expectations, structured policies, and thoughtful discussions, troops can create an environment where technology supports learning rather than hinders it.

Here’s how different leaders have tackled this issue and the strategies they recommend.

Challenges:

• Scouts often have continuous access to social media at school, making restrictions in scout group setting complicated.
• Distractions from devices can take away from meeting engagement.
• Privacy concerns arise when scouts take and post photos without permission.
• Inappropriate content can be accessed and shared, even outside scouting events.
• Resistance to restrictions—many scouts want access to their devices and need to learn responsible usage.

Suggested Solutions:

• Create a written agreement signed by families and scouts, outlining clear rules and consequences.
• Use a strike system to manage misuse (warnings, temporary removal, and parent involvement).
• Limit device access during scout activities, but allow supervised use when necessary.
• Teach responsible digital behavior by emphasizing cyber safety, social media etiquette, and permission-based photography.
• Empower instead of punish by helping scouts learn that devices are tools for navigation, research, and documentation rather than just for social media.
• Engage parents in discussions about device restrictions, asking for their input on locking apps or limiting access.
• Encourage alternatives like disposable cameras for trips to avoid phone distractions while keeping memories.
• Set up a designated phone table or basket—Scouts place their devices in a central location and can only use them at approved times, such as contacting parents or taking photos for a badge activity.

Each scout group manages devices differently, but the key goal is to balance real-world digital education with responsible usage in scouting spaces.

Real Life Examples

Here are some real challenges scout leaders have faced regarding device use in their troops, along with how they’ve managed those situations.

Balancing Social Media & Presence

Leaders noted that most scouts are already heavily involved in social media, whether at school or in their daily lives. Scouts often struggle with staying present, even during meetings or outdoor activities. Instead of banning devices outright, some scout groups choose to limit access and reserve the right to take them away if used inappropriately.

Privacy & Photography Rules

One scout group had a foster child who legally could not have their photo posted online for safety reasons. Leaders used this example to explain why posting troop photos requires more than just the scout’s permission—it requires parental approval. Scouts were encouraged to think critically before posting pictures and to respect everyone’s privacy, especially in situations they may not fully understand.

Setting Boundaries & Discipline

One scout group implemented a three-strike system to manage device use.

• First strike: A verbal warning reminding the scout to put their device away.
• Second strike: The scout hands their device to the leader for a short time (end of activity or five minutes).
• Third strike: The device is held until the end of the meeting or event and given directly to a parent.

On overnights, devices were returned each morning, with strikes resetting daily. Scouts were also responsible for their own content—leaders made it clear that monitoring apps or messages was the parents’ job, not the troop’s responsibility.

Inappropriate Conversations or Content

One scout leader recalled an experience where teens engaged in an inappropriate discussion about sensitive topics. Although no devices were involved, the situation was treated as seriously as if scouts had shared inappropriate content. The troop revisited their yearly behavior expectations, ensured families were notified, and followed a structured approach for incidents to maintain a respectful environment.

Device-Free Experiences vs. Practical Use

Some scout groups chose full device bans on trips, while others allowed limited use for practical purposes like taking photos, looking up information, or using maps. Leaders noted that teens must learn responsible phone use for adulthood, so empowering scouts to use devices as tools—rather than just for social media—was a better long-term strategy than outright bans. One leader encouraged scouts to hold them accountable, allowing them to call out the leader if they were on their phone too much.

Parent Collaboration & Written Policies

Leaders emphasized the importance of written agreements outlining device rules and consequences. Having all families and scouts sign a behavior contract prevented confusion and helped avoid complaints to council if devices had to be taken away. Some scout groups even worked with parents to lock apps for the duration of a trip rather than collecting devices.

–

Managing device use in scouting requires thoughtful rules and realistic expectations. The goal isn’t just control—it’s education, respect, and balanced engagement.

–

For More Fun Ideas and Plans

for Daisy, Brownie, and Junior Scouts

This is a supportive Facebook community for Daisy, Brownie, and Junior Girl Scout leaders. Whether you’re seeking advice, fresh ideas, or meeting plans, you’re in the right place! Let’s inspire each other, share our experiences, and make every troop meeting a memorable adventure.

for Cadette, Senior, and Ambassador Scouts

This is a supportive community for Cadette, Senior, and Ambassador Girl Scout leaders. This group offers solutions to keep older scouts engaged in scouting amidst their busy lives. Share strategies, tackle challenges, and exchange ideas for fun, meaningful activities that resonate with teens and build lasting connections.

Find out how you can support The Badge Archive!

–

• Return to the Daisy Badge List.
• Return to the Brownie Badge List.
• Return to the Junior Badge List.
• Return to the Cadette Badge List.
• Return to the Senior Badge List.
• Return to the Ambassador Badge List.

–